Skip to content
  • Bid scoring
  • UK
  • Procurement Act 2023

Why do we keep losing tenders? How UK bids are scored

How UK tenders are scored under the Procurement Act 2023, what an assessment summary must tell you when you lose, and how to use it on your next bid.

If a capable firm keeps losing tenders, look first at the written answers, because evaluators give marks for what the tender itself says against the published criteria. Under the Procurement Act 2023 the buyer has to tell you the scoring rules before you bid and, for most contracts above the threshold, give you your scores and the reasons afterwards. Reading both carefully is the most reliable way to improve.

Picture a firm that’s good at the work and knows it. Question after question, its tender says the requirements will be met. It doesn’t say how. The evaluators can only mark what’s on the page, so those answers can’t be given the higher scores, and a rival that explained its method comes out ahead. The firm loses again and puts it down to price.

It may not have been price at all, and where you’re entitled to an assessment summary, it should say. This guide applies to procurements started on or after 24 February 2025. Rules are as of 15 November 2026.

How are tenders assessed under the Procurement Act 2023?

After a competitive tendering procedure, a public contract can only be awarded to the supplier that submits the most advantageous tender, usually shortened to MAT. Cabinet Office guidance defines it as “the tender that both satisfies the contracting authority’s requirements and is the best tender when assessed against the award criteria and the assessment methodology”.

The old term was “most economically advantageous tender”. The guidance says the change is meant to reinforce “that tenders do not have to be awarded on the basis of lowest price/cost”. Price can be the only criterion, but the guidance says this “is unlikely to be suitable for most contracts”.

Award criteria have to meet four tests. They must:

  • relate to the subject-matter of the contract
  • be “sufficiently clear, measurable and specific”
  • comply with the rules on technical specifications
  • be a proportionate means of assessing tenders, having regard to the nature, complexity and cost of the contract

Where do I find the scoring rules before I bid?

In the tender notice and the tender documents. The guidance says buyers “must publish the award criteria and the assessment methodology, or a summary of the criteria, in the tender notice”, with the full detail in the associated documents if it isn’t in the notice.

What must be publishedWhat it means for you
Award criteriaThe questions and price elements your tender will be marked on
Relative importanceWeightings, a ranking, or another description of which criteria count most
Assessment methodologyHow marks are given, including “any scoring matrices to be used by evaluators”
Pass/fail rulesWhether failing one criterion disqualifies the whole tender

Evaluators are bound by this. The guidance says authorities “must base their assessment on the published assessment methodology and the relative importance of the award criteria”.

Here’s a real example of the level of detail you can expect. The tender notice for the G-Cloud 15 framework listed, for one lot, two quality criteria at 40% each, a social value criterion at 10% and two price criteria at 5% each, and pointed bidders to a quality questionnaire for each question’s “requirement, response guidance and marking scheme”.

So before you write a word, you can know what each answer is worth and what a top-scoring one has to show.

Why does a capable firm score low on quality questions?

Three features of the rules explain most of it.

Being good at the work is tested somewhere else

Your capacity as a supplier is checked through conditions of participation. The guidance draws the line clearly: conditions of participation decide “whether a supplier is capable/suitable to perform the contract”, while award criteria “determine the merits of the supplier’s tender”. The guidance on conditions of participation adds that once you pass the conditions, your tender “must be assessed in relation to the award criteria only”.

That’s why reputation and track record earn marks only where a question asks for them and you write them down.

Marks follow the scoring descriptors

The guidance on assessment summaries describes how a typical criterion works: to be awarded a particular score, “the tender must demonstrate that a number of requirements will be achieved”. Its own example of feedback for a tender that missed a higher score reads:

“Although the tender stated that [requirements x and y] would be met, the tender failed to explain how the proposed solution met those requirements and therefore failed to demonstrate [requirement x] and [requirement y] would be delivered. This meant the tender could not be awarded a higher score.”

Saying you’ll do something and showing how you’ll do it are scored differently. The firm in the scene above did the first.

Procedural slips can remove you altogether

A buyer may disregard a tender that breaches a procedural requirement in the tender notice or documents. The guidance gives two examples: “the tender is submitted late or the tender is over the prescribed word count”.

What must the buyer tell me when I lose?

Where a public contract is awarded after a competitive tendering procedure, the buyer must give an assessment summary to every supplier that submitted an assessed tender. It must go to all of them at the same time, and before the contract award notice is published.

The summary must includeDetail
The award criteriaAt least the title of each criterion, its relative importance, how it was to be assessed and the scores available
Your score for each criterionIncluding each sub-criterion, any sub-totals and the total
A reason for each scoreBy reference to “relevant information in the tender”
The winner’s scores and reasonsThe same information for the most advantageous tender, redacted where it is commercially sensitive
Any other reason you were not awarded the contractFor example, disqualification for missing a minimum score

Buyers are told they “cannot simply repeat the award criterion and state ‘the tender demonstrated x’ or ‘failed to demonstrate y’”. The guidance adds that explaining why a higher score was not achieved is best practice.

The buyer doesn’t have to compare your tender directly with the winner’s. You get both sets of scores, and the guidance says a supplier reading the two “will be able to ascertain the relative advantages”.

Where does the right run out?

  • Framework call-offs are outside it. The requirement “does not apply when awarding a contract in accordance with a framework”, although the guidance calls a similar approach best practice.
  • When a multi-supplier framework is itself awarded, the guidance says the buyer should give losing bidders the scores of the lowest scoring successful tender, as the best indication of the gap they needed to close.
  • If you were knocked out at an earlier stage, you didn’t submit an assessed tender. The buyer should still tell you in writing as soon as reasonably possible.
  • The guidance covers public contracts only, which broadly means contracts above the threshold.
  • General advice on improving future bids is optional. The guidance says there is “no legal requirement to provide feedback of this nature but it may be particularly useful for small and medium-sized enterprises or new entrants to the market”.

Feedback has been a known weak point. According to SME Web’s coverage of a Federation of Small Businesses report from December 2025, only one in 20 small firms that bid received comprehensive and actionable feedback on why they lost.

How do I use an assessment summary?

The summary must reach you before the contract award notice is published. That notice starts the standstill period, which lasts at least eight working days. The guidance on standstill says the period gives suppliers the chance “to raise any concerns about, or formally challenge, the award decision before the contract is entered into”. So read the summary on the day it arrives.

The steps below are my own suggestions for working through it. They are not an official process.

  1. Put every criterion in a table with its weighting, your score, the winner’s score and the reason given for each.
  2. Multiply each gap by its weighting. The largest figures show where you lost the most marks.
  3. For those questions, set the buyer’s reasons beside your answer and the published scoring descriptor. Mark each requirement the descriptor lists that your answer stated without explaining.
  4. Compare the scores and reasons with the published methodology. If one doesn’t seem to fit, consider raising it with the buyer in writing inside the standstill period.
  5. Ask for any general feedback the buyer is willing to give.
  6. Keep the table and compare it with the next one, so you can see whether the same kinds of question keep costing you marks.

For a framework call-off, ask for the same breakdown and point to the best practice wording in the guidance.

Which bid habits follow from the published rules?

These come from the guidance above and from the Government Commercial Agency’s own guide to writing bids.

  • Answer the question that was asked. The agency says: “Make sure you fully understand the questions in the bid before writing your answers. If you are unsure what is being asked, ask your own clarification questions.”
  • Write to the scoring descriptor. If the top score requires five things to be demonstrated, give the answer five clearly marked parts.
  • Give evidence for each claim. The agency asks for “the most recent and relevant evidence and experience” and warns against “generic statements like ‘customer service is at the heart of what we do’”.
  • Don’t recycle old answers. “Submitting generic or responses from previous bids” is first on the agency’s list of common mistakes.
  • Stay inside word counts and formatting rules. “Exceeding word counts or ignoring formatting requirements” is on the same list, and the Act lets a buyer disregard the tender.
  • Use plain language, with sentences of 15 to 20 words and short paragraphs, as the agency recommends.
  • Have someone who didn’t write the bid review it against the original specification.
  • Spend effort in proportion to the weightings. A question worth 40% deserves more of your time than one worth 5%.

These habits matter because quality criteria are widely used. The Open Contracting Partnership’s analysis of the first year of Procurement Act data found quality criteria used in 66% of lots in open procedures and 74% in competitive flexible procedures.

If the tender period itself is your problem, see how long UK tenders stay open for the notices that give earlier warning.

Sources

All opened on 15 November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

How are tenders scored in the UK?

Each tender is assessed against award criteria that the buyer publishes in the tender notice or tender documents, using a published assessment methodology such as a scoring matrix. Where there is more than one criterion, the buyer must state their relative importance, usually as percentage weightings.

Does the lowest price win a government tender?

Not necessarily. The contract goes to the most advantageous tender. Cabinet Office guidance says price can be the sole criterion but that this 'is unlikely to be suitable for most contracts', and buyers may weigh quality, technical and social factors alongside price.

Why did my tender score low on quality?

Your assessment summary should tell you. Official guidance tells buyers to explain each score by reference to information in your tender, and gives the example of a tender that stated requirements would be met but 'failed to explain how the proposed solution met those requirements'.

Am I entitled to feedback on an unsuccessful tender?

For a public contract awarded after a competitive tendering procedure, yes, if your tender was assessed at the final stage. You must receive an assessment summary before the contract award notice is published. Wider coaching on how to improve is optional for the buyer.

How long is the standstill period after a contract award notice?

The standstill period is at least eight working days, beginning with the day the contract award notice is published. The buyer can't enter into the contract during that time. Some contracts, including framework call-offs, have no mandatory standstill.

Can a tender be rejected for going over the word count?

Yes. The guidance on assessing tenders lists a tender that is submitted late or 'over the prescribed word count' as an example of a breach of a procedural requirement, which allows the buyer to disregard it.

Written by Ketul Shah

Ketul Shah is the founder of TrackTender, a tender alert service that runs in India. These guides are researched from official UK sources, which are listed at the end of each one.

More about TrackTender →

Want this as a daily list?

TrackTender is not open in the UK yet. Join the waiting list and we will write once when it is.

Join the waiting list